Geo. W. Gayle, Frankfort, KY
George W. Gayle and his son Clarence Gayle began making reels around 1883. George Gayle was a silversmith and learned reel making while he worked for J.F.& B.F. Meek. Clarence Gayle, however, was the main person involved in making the Gayle reels. His reels can be found made of solid German silver and of aluminum. The "Standard" Gayle reel has a flanged headplate that looks like a man's top hat. The "Kentucky" style Gayle's are the most ornate and heavily knurled reels and are of the highest quality. Gayle also made a reels for the famous tackle companies VL&A, Chicago and William Mills & Son, NY. The William Mills & Son models were named "Intrinsic". "Intrinsic" reels came in the "Standard" and "Kentucky" styles and had extra fancy knurling. The Gayle fly reel is made of aluminum and is also sought after by collectors. George died in 1896.
Later Gayle History - Clarence continued to make reels after his father's death up until the 1940’s. Clarence started marking his reels “HAND MADE” in about 1930. The last reels were marked “HAND MADE” and the maker’s name “CGayle” in script. Clarence did make some reels using B.C. Milam & Sons parts he had acquired when that company dissolved in 1928. Clarence died in 1948. The latest ad I've seen is from a 1937 issue of Field & Stream magazine.

The GAYLE NO. 1 Reel, circa 1900

The GAYLE NO. 3 German Silver and Hard Rubber Reel, circa 1900

The GAYLE NO. 3 German Silver Reel, circa 1900

The GAYLE NO. 3 Reel, circa 1900

The GAYLE NO. 3 Reel, circa 1910

The GAYLE Multiplying Aluminum Fly Reel, circa 1910

The GAYLE INTRINSIC Standard Reel, circa 1915

The GAYLE INTRINSIC Kentucky Reel, circa 1915
The GAYLE Fly Reel, circa 1915

The GAYLE No. 4 Reel, circa 1915

Marked "Made for VL&A, Chicago, by Geo. Gayle & Son, Frankfort, KY", circa 1900

1900 Ad for the VL&A Gayle Reel

The GAYLE Reel Showing Surface Copper Oxide Patina From the Nickel Silver
Outing Magazine, Dr. Henshall's Evolution of the Kentucky Reel, Dec. 1900
Forrest and Stream Magazine, Interview with J. L. Sage, Jan. 1915
Forrest and Stream Magazine, Dr. Henshall's More About The Kentucky Reel, Feb. 1915